top of page

Spring Street property owner appeals changes in axe factory zone

By John Fitts

Staff Writer


CANTON – The owner of a property on Spring Street in Collinsville has appealed the Canton Planning and Zoning Commission’s approval of changes in the Industrial Heritage 1 (IH1) Zone that regulates re-development of the axe factory complex.

Set on approximately 19 acres along the Farmington River, the complex was home to The Collins Company, a world famous manufacturer of edge tools, from 1826 to the mid 1966. Today, some 45 small businesses operate in a portion of the remaining buildings but many of the approximately 25 structures are in various states of disrepair and several are currently uninhabitable.

Sheldon Stein of New York-based Ranger Properties has an option to purchase the property and this summer he and his team proposed several changes in the zone to facilitate redevelopment.

The changes for the IH1 zone, known as a text amendment, also included an updated master plan for the property, which shows three new residential buildings and a mix of residential and commercial uses for the existing structures. However, that master plan is a general visualization of a how a development could look. A much more detailed, construction level proposal would come with a specific site plan.

The Planning and Zoning Commission approved nearly all the proposed text changes for the zone at its Aug. 18 meeting and the lawsuit from Tyler Nye of Scranton, Pa., who owns 15-17 Spring St. in Collinsville, alleges the commission’s approval was “illegal, arbitrary, and/or capricious, and an abuse of the discretion vested in it.”

Both the commission and Stein are listed as defendants in the Superior Court appeal, filed by Cramer & Anderson, LLP of New Milford.

The appeal asserts Nye is “statutorily aggrieved” since his property is within 100 feet of the complex and notes a change in property setbacks from 30 feet to 10 feet, a change developers said would help accommodate a planned parking structure but one that did raise some concern from the public. (Developers say the parking garage would be tucked into the hillside but the idea has generosity some controversy over whether it could have a visual or audible impact). The appeal also alleges other potential impacts to area property owners.

Among the assertions listed in the appeal are allegations the decision was not based on evidence, violates the town’s Plan of Conservation and Development and is “inconsistent” with commission mandates to “promote public health, safety and general welfare” and to “secure safety from fire, flood other dangers.”

Another section alleges the changes were done to maximize profits and reduce risk for those looking to re-develop the property.

The appeal also alleges the commission did not “reasonably” take into account the historic nature of the complex and the impact the changes would permit.

The appeal also alleges that the decision reduces regulatory oversight and exempts some work from “general permitting standards and other requirements” that other properties in town are subject to.

The appeal, in one section, for example, notes that the changes allow “Any earthwork and grading ‘regardless of volume’ to occur without the need for the applicant to obtain a special permit under Sections 6.2 (‘Flood Plain Management’) and/or 7.5 (‘Earthwork and Grading’) of the Regulations.”

During the hearings, at least one commissioner did express concern that the lack of special permit hearings for the project could stifle public input since a site plan application – one of the next major steps in the process – would not necessarily requiring a public hearing.

During the summer meetings, Neil Pade the town’s director of Planning and Community Development, noted the commission can – and should – hold a public hearing when the site plan is filed and Planning and Zoning Commission Jonathan Thiesse said special permits are generally used to determine if a use is appropriate on a particular property within a larger zone – not for a single zone site.

At the summer hearing, members of the development team said the request to clarify that special permits referenced in other zoning sections are not needed for the IH1 zone is one of process, expressing concerns that permits could potentially be required at several points during the project, delaying progress. But developers also said the lack of special permits does not exempt them from meeting the zoning standards.

“When we get to the site plan, we want to move the process through in a consistent and relatively streamlined process, so whether it’s earthwork and grading, floodplain management, landscaping or retaining walls, but primarily earthwork and grading and floodplain management, the narrative we’ve proposed says we’ll meet all the standards but we’re not going to be subject to special permit criteria because we don’t want to have additional public hearings on those as we move forward,” Phil Doyle, of Simsbury based Landscape Architectural Design Associates said at the July hearing.

The new language in the regulations for the zone states that while a special permit is not required, “all earthwork and grading shall be consistent with the purpose of Zoning; provide for restoration and development of the property; comply with the standards of Section 6.2 and 7.5; and, where applicable, obtain a permit from the Canton IWWA (Inland Wetlands and Watercourses Agency).”

The legal action includes two counts of administrative appeal with the second focusing on historic preservation and the property’s location within the boundaries of a national register of Historic places Historic District and alleges the commission did not properly look into alternatives and acted “illegally, arbitrarily, or capriciously and abused its discretion” in not considering potential “negative effects” or “feasible and prudent alternatives.”

During the public hearing on the proposed text changes, Stein’s team requested a change to the section of the zone stating “The restoration and renovation of existing buildings will be consistent with the secretary of Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings.” Stein’s team requested language to change the words “consistent with” to “sensitive to,” noting that they did not plan to apply for historic preservation grants, asserting that it was prohibitive and the current conditions of the buildings make that impractical.

“The buildings have gotten to the point where the feasibility of that today is highly unlikely,” Doyle said at the July hearing. “It was unlikely, actually, when it was proposed 20 years ago …conditions today are very much deteriorated so we have a proposal that will not be looking for [those] grants.”

At the advice of the local Collinsville Historic District Commission, the adopted language uses the term “reasonably consistent.”

The appeal asserts that the changes open the door to degrading the historic character of the complex through the use of less authentic materials, architecture and structures.

In previous meetings, Stein asserted that he has a real passion for breathing new life into historic properties and working with towns to come up with quality projects.

“We came to this project about 6 or 8 months ago and really love the existing bones of the axe factory and have a real passion to restore old properties that have great history and great bones that really want for redevelopment,” Stein said at the July hearing.

Last week, Stein expressed disappointment in the appeal.

“We are disappointed a neighbor would file an appeal but remain extremely committed to the Collins Axe property development and don’t foresee the appeal materially delaying our schedule,” he said. “The Town and its boards have been extremely good partners and supportive in the land use application process and we expect they will remain steadfast as this is exhausted in the courts.”

Messages to the commission’s attorney had not been returned as of press time. An email sent to Nye was also unanswered as of late last week,


Related Posts

See All

Valley Happenings

Canton Community Health Fund Applications Canton Community Health Fund, Inc. Opens 2025 Application Season, on March 1, 2025, for Canton...

VAL_01.jpg
WHL_01.jpg

Valley Happenings

UPDATED:

Fighting Cancer Pasta Dinner:

Benefit for Avon Volunteer Fire Department

Deputy Chief Dave Theriault

Sunday, February 23, 2025, 3:00-7:00 p.m. 

Farmington Polo Club, 162 Town Farm Road, Farmington

 

AVFD Deputy Chief of Administration Dave Theriault is facing a tough battle against Stage 4 cancer. The AVFD, along with Tunxis Hose Co. No. 1 and the Farmington Fire Department, is holding a pasta dinner to help raise money for Chief Theriault’s medical expenses. Cheese and crackers from 3:00-4:00 p.m., buffet from 4:00-6:00 p.m., and coffee and dessert from 6:00-7:00 p.m. In addition to delicious food, drinks, and camaraderie, the event will feature dozens of raffle prizes. Event tickets are $20 for adults and $10 for seniors and children under 10 years old. They can be purchased at the door or online at www.HometownFoundation.org Contributions can be made via Venmo @supportDave or by mail to the AVFD at 25 Darling Drive, Avon, CT 06001. 

Canton Community Health Fund Applications

Canton Community Health Fund, Inc. Opens 2025 Application Season, on March 1, 2025, for Canton Community Partner Grants & Canton Scholars Pursuing Careers in Healthcare or Public Safety Canton Community Health Fund, Inc. (CCHF), opens its grant and scholarship application season March 1. CCHF encourages State of CT certified non-profits serving the Canton community to apply for Community Partner grants. In addition, graduating high school seniors seeking higher education in healthcare or public safety are invited to apply for either a Dr. Diters Legacy Scholarship or a Pay It Forward Scholarship. Applications and informative Fact Sheets are available online at www.cantoncommunityhealthfund.org.  Community Partner Grant and Scholarship awards will be announced in June/2025.

 

Avon Library events

AVON –The following events are scheduled at Avon Free Public Library. The library is at Avon Library, 281 Country Club Road, Avon. All programs are in person except where noted. For more information on adult programs, contact Adult Services Reference Desk via avonref@avonctlibrary.info 860-673-9712 x 7203

• Antique Map Collecting 101, Saturday, Feb. 1 at 1 p.m. Registration is required: https://www.avonctlibrary.info/event/antique-map-collecting/

• Morning Book Club. Wednesday, Feb. 5 at 10:30 a.m., The Mystery Guest by Nita Prose, Registration is required: https://www.avonctlibrary.info/events/tag/morning-book-club/

• Meditation for Balance and Inner Contentment. (Virtual Event) Thursday, Feb. 6 at 7 pm.

• Eastern Coyotes in Connecticut (Virtual Event) Thursday, Feb. 13 at 6:30 p.m.

• Fashion and the First Lady (Virtual Event). Wednesday, Feb. 19 at 2 p.m.

• Hoop Skirts to Flappers: Eighty Years of Connecticut Fashion. Monday, Feb. 24 at 2 p.m.

• The Golden Age of Hollywood. (Virtual Event) Tuesday, March 4 at 2 pm.

 

Simsbury Lions Club

The Simsbury Lions Club is looking for people interested in volunteering and contributing to better our town. Our motto is “We serve,” and we do so by volunteering at local events and donating our proceeds to serving interests in our community.

If interested, please feel free to contact Sandy Kremer at Tprkremer@gmail.com or Philip Painchaud at painchaudp@gmail.com.”

 

Winter sowing workshop

The Farmington Land trust is hosting a winter sowing workshop focused on raising native plants. Make your own up-cycled greenhouse from a milk jug and prep some beneficial native plants for the coming growing season. Sunday, Feb 2 from 11a.m.-12:30 p.m. at the Farmington Senior Center. RSVP here: https://www.farmingtonlandtrust.org/event-details/winter-sowing-seminar-native-seed-planting

 

Wild Flowers from Spring to Fall

CANTON – The Cherry Brook Garden Club is hosting a lecture on “Following Our Wild Flowers from Spring to Fall” on Tuesday, Feb. 11, at 11 a.m. at the Canton Community Center, lower level, 40 Dyer Avenue. Steve Messier, Lichenologist and former Science teacher at Canton High School will discuss the topic. The lecture is open to the public. There is a $5 guest fee for non-members. Email questions to cherrybrookgardenclub@gmail.com.

 

‘Five Wishes’ at McLean

SIMSBURY – Join Kevin Baran, M.D., medical director, and the McLean Hospice Team for a special “McLean & Me Educational Series” presentation to learn how to talk about and record your wishes for care through the end of life, so those wishes can be understood and respected. The presentation will be held at McLean’s Garmany Performing Arts Center, 50 Sarah Lane, Simsbury, on Tuesday, Feb. 11, at 6 p.m. The presentation is free but an RSVP by Feb. 4 is required as seating is limited. A light dinner will be provided.

To register, visit McLeanCare.org/Events, email Margaret.Clark@McLeanCare.org, or call 860-658-3718.

 

‘Art Throb!’ Exhibit

Gallery on the Green presents “Art Throb!” Exhibit plus a Solo Exhibit by Kathi Packer Friday, Feb. 14 through Saturday, March 15. An opening reception is on Saturday, Feb. 15 from 6-8 p.m. and will include refreshments. The show and reception are free.

“Art Throb!” is a heartfelt Valentine’s Day celebration presented by the membership of Canton Artists’ Guild. The artists use a wide range of media including painting, prints, drawing, photography, sculpture, ceramics and mixed media to represent the emotional intensity, joy and complexity of love.

In the upstairs Gallery, Kathi Packer has a solo show, “Another Tale.”  Packer notes that a friend’s casual invitation to go on safari in 2008 substantially changed the direction of her artistic journey.The gallery is located near the intersection of Dowd Avenue and Route 44 at 5 Canton Green Road in Canton. Hours are Friday – Sunday, 1-5 pm. The main floor gallery is handicapped accessible.

Website: http://www.galleryonthegreen.org; Phone:  860-693-4102

 

TABLESCAPES fundraiser returns to benefit the new

Avon History Museum

AVON – The Avon Historical Society invites the public to its sixth TABLESCAPES event showcasing up to 30 creative and original table settings on Friday, March 14 and Saturday, March 15 at the historic North House, 1 Nod Road, Avon.

This event will feature themed table settings from local professional designers, florists, businesses, individuals, artists and others featuring fresh floral arrangements, centerpieces and accessories. Proceeds will benefit the installation of professionally curated exhibits in the new Avon History Museum scheduled to open on Friday, July 4, 2025.

Back by popular demand will be a “Table and Barware Tag Sale” on both days. Admission to TABLESCAPES includes the tag sale. Tickets are $20 each pre-sale and at the door. Tickets can be purchased online at www.avonhistoricalsociety.org or by calling Mary Harrop at 860-670-3225 before March 8.

Those interested in sponsorship opportunities can also call Harrop.

 

Alzheimer’s Support Group

FARMINGTON – Hearts, Hugs & Hope: An Alzheimer’s Support Group takes place Feb. 20, 2025, 6 p.m. at Farmington Station Assisted Living and Memory Care Community, 111 Scott Swamp Road, Farmington. Dealing with Alzheimer’s disease and related dementia isn’t easy, so it is helpful to share your concerns and personal experiences with others who completely understand what you’re going through. You will also learn about proven strategies to help you better care for your family member. This group is being offered both in person and via Zoom on the third Thursday of each month. If you plan to attend, contact Director of Compass Programming Katherine Jedynasty at kjedynasty@farmingtonslr.com.

 

Used book sale

AVON - A huge book sale will be held Feb. 28 and March 1 in St. Ann’s Church Hall, 289 Arch Road at Route 167.  Hours are Friday, 4 p.m. to 7 p.m. ($5 adult admission) and Saturday, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. (no admission fee).

Thousands of books will be organized in separate sections, including Fiction, History, Biography, Politics, Children, Music, Cooking, Sports, Art, Vintage, and more!  A large selection of Children’s books will be available.  Fiction books will be divided by hardcover, paperback, and trade paperback and sorted alphabetically by author.  DVDs, CDs, books on CDs, Vinyl records, and puzzles will be available, also.  Most books will be $3 or less with vintage and specialty books priced higher.

 

Daisy Days: All-Girls Summer Day Camp Experience

FARMINGTON – Miss Porter’s School, a renowned institution with a legacy of empowering young women, is excited to announce the launch of Daisy Days, an all-new day camp for girls entering grades 3-5 this fall. Starting this summer, Daisy Days will offer a unique, joy-filled experience designed to spark creativity, build confidence, and inspire self-discovery in an empowering all-girls environment.

For additional details, visit pcgl.porters.org/daisy-days.

 

Artist demonstration

Avon Arts Association will hold a guest artist demonstration featuring  Granby artist Laura Eden on Tuesday, February 18 at  Avon Town Hall, 60 W. Main St., lower level, at 6:30 p.m. Ms. Eden will demonstrate egg tempera painting.

The demo is free and open to the public ($5 suggested donation). A workshop with Ms. Eden will be held at the same location in the Avon Room on Saturday, Feb. 22, 10-2 with  set up at 9:30. Fee: $45 for members, $55 for nonmembers). www.AvonArts.org

Have a press release or story idea? Send me a note.

Thanks for submitting!

© 2023 by Train of Thoughts. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page